megz_mum

Thursday, March 09, 2006

"Saturday" by Ian McEwan

Here is a little summary of this month's bookclub book.
Nine out of eleven bookclub members loved this book. Several members particularly mentioned the opening of the book as being an excellent attention-grabber. Nearly everyone felt that the book and suspense were wonderfully paced. Everyone loved the beautiful prose, and felt the descriptive passages were a joy to read. Several members mentioned their inability to put the book down, reading the book very quickly. Overtones/links with/a feeling of similarity were mentioned with regard to another Ian McEwan book we read "Atonement", particularly towards the end of the book (don't want to spoil the ending if you are intending to read it). Mention was made of the detailed descriptions of surgery/medical conditions/poetry/music which indicated very thorough research. Many felt the character of Perowne and his relationships with his family were wonderfully written.

My thoughts about the book - I was one of the two who were not totally appreciative of "Saturday". I thought the writing was beautiful, but there was such a lack of plot/action, I found it a real struggle. I read to page 143 (out of 279) and still felt like the scene was being set, with nothing exciting happening. I had a moment of hope when Perowne was involved in a minor car accident - I loved that scene and had high hopes, but then there was the squash game...... on and on....Maybe my attention span is too short for beautiful writing, I need a bit of plot to keep me going. Bookclub suggested giving it another 10 pages, then things really start to happen, so will have to do that - but not more than 15 pages!! I also felt a bit "had" that this was being described as "one day" when so much of the book was dedicated to the history of various characters, admittedly as part of the scene-setting. I am the Queen of daydreaming, yet I would be hard pushed to have that many extensive thoughts in one day!

In summary, part of the quote from The Sydney Morning Herald quoted in the front of the book - "The joy of the novel is in the writing, not the subject matter"

1 Comments:

  • At 11:06 AM, March 10, 2006, Blogger Meow (aka Connie) said…

    Hi, thanks for coming over to visit. It is nice to meet another fellow Aussie !!!
    I haven't read "Saturday", so I cannot comment ... sounds good, though. Must get on down to the library to borrow it !!
    Hope you have a great weekend ... your weather is still very warm, isn't it ? We are expecting mid to high 30s this weekend, so it will be a ripper !! Don't know if you know the area, but Bonnie Doon is on Lake Eildon, so we will be spending plenty of water-time this weekend, I guess !!
    Have a good one, take care, Meow

     

Post a Comment

<< Home