Last week I received an email with the "Neiman Marcus" biscuit story, a bit of an urban myth. This email has landed in my "inbox" several times, but I have previously just ignored it.
This time, however, I decided to try the recipe and to delve a little into the story.
So here are two links you may wish to follow -
this one to the Neiman Marcus website and their take on the story,
this one to a site that discusses the myth of charging for the recipe and, interestingly, there have been versions of charging exorbitant prices for a recipe in various forms for a long time!
Now to the actual recipe - the result is pictured above.
The recipe attached to the email ( and discussed in the link above) is different to the one on the Neiman Marcus website.
I thought I would try the recipe exactly as is to make a fair judgment of the biscuits. To be honest, it wasn't
exactly as the recipe stated as I halved the amounts - I would have enough to feed a small army if I had made the whole recipe! However, the relative amounts remained the same (I am sure you understood that, just had a little teeny ramble there!)
My first impression was that there was an awful lot of chocolate involved - and in my humble opinion, if you are going to cook with chocolate, the end result has to warrant its use as it is pretty scrummy without cooking it or adding it to recipes.
So, all baked and the biscuit barrel and one extra container is full.
The verdict?
We have high standards for chocolate chip biscuits in our house. The Gold Standard for Chocolate Chip biscuits for us is the Australian Womens Weekly Chocolate chip biscuit recipe. This has been made, unaltered, for many years now and is a much requested biscuit by the girls and their friends.
So the AWW recipe scores a 10 out of 10.
The email "Neiman Marcus" choc chip recipe biscuit was given an 8 or 9 out of 10. Still pretty good, but not good enough to replace our favourite.
To be honest, I am not sure having all that chocolate added to the end result, it seemed to meld and not be noticeable. Maybe I should have left the chunks a bit bigger.
The ground up oats did make for an interesting texture, I might try the base and add in dates and ginger instead of the chocolate chips and chocolate bar.
Anyway, here is the email Neiman Marcus biscuit recipe (and note that it is different to the recipe on their website)
Neiman Marcus Cookies (recipe may be halved)
2 cups (500ml) butter
24oz (680g) chocolate chips
4 cups (1000ml) flour
2 cups brown sugar
2 cups castor sugar
2 tsp bicarb soda
2 tsp baking powder
2 tsp vanilla essence
1 tsp salt
18 oz (500g) Hershey bar (Cadbury chocolate), grated
5 cups oatmeal, blended
4 eggs
3 cups nuts, chopped (optional)
1. Blend oatmeal to a fine powder
2. Cream butter and both sugars
3. Add eggs and vanilla, mix with flour, oatmeal, salt, baking soda and bicarb soda
4. Add chocolate chips and grated chocolate, also nuts if using
5. Roll into balls, place on a greased oven tray and bake at 375F or 180C for 10-12 minutes
Makes approximately 112 biscuits
Let me know how you go!